The Probation Period: What You Need To Know

The probation period in Ontario, is utilized in testing and shaping the relationship between employers and employees during the initial stages of the employment relationship. This period provides employers with a window of opportunity to assess the suitability of a new employee for a particular role while allowing employees to demonstrate their potential and compatibility within the organization. 

This article will look into the employment probation period in Ontario, what both employees and employers need to be aware of, and the role of an employment lawyer in navigating this crucial phase.

Understanding the Probation Period in Ontario

The probation period is a predetermined time frame where employers can terminate an employee without providing notice or severance. Generally, these periods extend from the commencement of employment to around three months after the employee’s hiring date. However, it is essential to note that Ontario has no automatic probation period by default. Instead, employers must explicitly outline a probationary period clause in the employment contract to make use of this provision and trial period.

If an employment contract contains an enforceable probation clause, they can terminate an employee at any time when it is determined that the employee is not a suitable fit for the position. However, it is important to note that if the employer terminates an employee during a probation period that exceeds three months, the employee may be entitled to termination and/or severance pay. 

Is a 3-Month Probationary Period Mandatory in Ontario?

No. In the Ontario Employment Standards Act, 2000 (“ESA“), there is no specific statutory term defined for probationary periods. Instead, probationary periods are established through the terms of individual employment contracts. Employers must include a probationary period clause in the employment contract to utilize this provision.

It’s important to note that, while the ESA doesn’t obligate employers to provide mandatory termination pay within the initial three (3) months of employment, this period is not considered a probationary period under the law.

Enforceability of Probation Period Clauses

The enforceability of a probation period clause relies on the clarity and specificity with which it is presented in the employment contract. Key considerations for enforceability include:

• Expressed In Writing: A probationary clause should be explicitly written in the contract, leaving no room for ambiguity or assumptions.
• Clarity and Ambiguity: Ambiguous or vague clauses may be deemed unenforceable. Employers can ensure enforceability by clearly stating the probation period’s terms in an employee’s employment agreement.
• Comply with Minimum Standards: Probation clauses cannot provide less than the minimum employment standards set by the Ontario Employment Standards Act, 2000. Employers must commit to providing minimum standards of notice, termination pay, and severance after three months if the probation period extends beyond this timeframe.

Termination Within the Probation Period

Terminating an employee during the minimum three-month probationary period is subject to a different standard than non-probationary employment. While “just cause” is required for dismissal without notice or pay in lieu of notice for regular employees, the standard for dismissal from probationary employment is the lower threshold of “suitability”.

Suitability considerations include:

• Performance: Assessing the employee’s performance and whether they meet job requirements and expectations.
• Attitude and Compatibility: Evaluating the employee’s ability to work well with colleagues and the overall organization.
• Capability and Skill: Determining whether the employee possesses the necessary skills to perform their role effectively.
• Capacity to Meet Future Standards: Measuring the employee’s potential to meet evolving standards and expectations of the employer, especially in fast-paced work environments.

During a new employee’s probation period, employers should engage in regular performance reviews, provide constructive feedback, and allow probationary employees a reasonable opportunity to address any deficiencies and demonstrate their suitability fairly and honestly. Therefore, the employer must act in good faith and provide employees with a fair and reasonable opportunity to demonstrate their suitability for the position.

Can an Employer Extend the Probationary Period?

Yes, an employee’s probationary period can be extended, but this must be clearly stated in the employment contract. Employers typically do this if they need more time to assess an employee’s suitability. Extensions are considered if the employee isn’t meeting job requirements, has attendance issues, or doesn’t align with the company’s values.

However, extending the probationary period isn’t automatic. The original employment contract must allow for it. If not, trying to extend it without this right can be seen as constructive dismissal, which may lead to legal consequences.

If it’s allowed in the contract, the extension must be done fairly. And, if it goes beyond 90 days, the employer must provide notice or pay as per the Employment Standards Act.

Employers should consult with an employment lawyer before terminating an employee. Dismissed employees who may not have received proper severance should also seek legal advice to explore potential remedies.

How an Employment Lawyer Can Help

Navigating the complexities of employment law during the probationary period can be tricky for both employers and employees. An experienced employment lawyer can provide valuable guidance and support throughout this crucial phase of the employment relationship.

For Employers

• Legal Compliance: An employment lawyer can help employers draft clear and enforceable probationary period clauses within employment contracts. They ensure the language is specific, understandable, transparent, and compliant with relevant laws.
• Termination Procedures: If an employer needs to terminate a probationary employee, an employment lawyer can guide them through the process to ensure that it’s done fairly, honestly, and within legal bounds. They can help employers avoid potential legal disputes that might arise from mishandled terminations.
• Dispute Resolution: In cases where a terminated probationary employee raises concerns about wrongful dismissal, an employment lawyer can represent the employer in negotiations or legal proceedings, aiming to resolve disputes efficiently.

For Employees

• Contract Review: An employment lawyer can review employment contracts before employees sign them, ensuring that probationary clauses, among other provisions, are clear and fair. They can advise employees on their rights and obligations during the probation period.
• Unfair Dismissal Claims: If an employee believes they were unfairly dismissed during the probationary period, an employment lawyer can assess the situation, determine if there are grounds for a claim, and guide the employee through the process of seeking compensation or reinstatement.
• Negotiations: In cases where an employee wishes to negotiate terms with their employer, such as extending the probationary period or addressing concerns, an employment lawyer can provide strategic advice and assistance during negotiations.
• Legal Representation: If a dispute escalates to legal action, an employment lawyer can represent the employee’s interests in negotiations, mediation, or litigation, aiming to achieve a fair resolution.

Conclusion

The probation period in Ontario plays a significant role in establishing a foundation for the employment relationship. Employers and employees must be aware of their rights, obligations, and the legal framework surrounding probationary periods and clauses. By understanding the requirements for enforceability, assessing suitability for the role, and seeking assistance from experienced employment lawyers when needed, both parties can navigate the probationary period with greater confidence and transparency. 

Related Articles

• Termination Entitlements: Factors Courts Consider
• Ontario Employment Standards Act, 2000: Your Handbook
• Why Does My Employment Agreement Have a Termination Clause?

Contact Achkar Law

If you’re facing employment law challenges, you’re not alone. Our dedicated team of employment law professionals is here to provide you with the support, guidance, and representation you need to navigate through complex legal matters with confidence.

Don’t Wait for Matters to Escalate

Schedule Your Confidential Consultation Today – Reach out to us to discuss your situation in a private and secure setting. Our consultation process is designed to give you the insights and options you need to move forward.

Your initial consultation is the first step towards resolving your employment law concerns.

Fill out our contact form.

Call us today toll-free: 1 (800) 771-7882.

Let’s work together towards a positive outcome.